Monday, June 20, 2016

Time and Greatness

What we call "Time" (if indeed a "what" can at all be appropriately applied) is in fact a greater background. Consider how Time arises in relation to the face-to-face encounter: the person comes into-and-out-of our lifespace, our personal vantage point. In this arising of appearance, this coming-near or proximity, there lay the clue to our question concerning Time's greatness. When the other person disappears, it is as it were a disappearance into the great background of the world. And so, the other transcends proximity, being-there only in terms of varying degrees of closeness and remoteness, immediacy and mediacy. Abstractly construed, this degree admits of a thinking in which the other is removed from us—not by some mere spatiality, but—by a temporal distance. This temporal distance is itself a background (and as such, a condition) for the dimensions we call space.

Though one studied philosophy, one is not as yet a philosopher, not of the highest rank. But such talk is theological at base. The thinker must think about time. Thinking God as Time is a thinking of life as miraculous, wondrous. Time as Father-of-All. Nature as Mother-of-All. These are pagan thoughts, yet they are too the thoughts of science, so that a deep truth comes to light in consideration of them, one that might even go far to repair theology from the violence of historical conquests carried out in His Name.

Under current standards of scholarship, Time appears within the Hindu Pantheon as if the image of a tripartite deity, Past, Present, Future; so that there is a necessity of critique in light of the monotheological, the idea of a single God over all other gods (deva-deva jagat-pate). The transformation of the many gods into demons (into images of avarice toward the monotheological), flows in many ways from the exigencies of historical consideration concerning the chief human virtues demonstrated in the light of history itself: ye shall know the tree by its fruits. A knowledge of history requires training in rigor and care for the fragile condition under which any such history leads humanity to a greater flourishing by having a greater view of itself in the light given by historical understanding.

 South Asian religions of numerous varieties are still called to respond to the question of monotheism. The culture of the Bible, and the culture of the Veda are both great plants, born in the soil of the everyday world. Thinking theologically means caring for these plants, and finding practical, insightful ways of leading them to flourishing.

Considering Time gives us pause to regard the conditions under which South Asian religions respond to contemporary theology. Its own history demonstrates a deep concern for the historical through the envisioning of these tripartite deities, Brahmā, Viṣṇu, Śiva. They are later products of a thinking which perhaps began even from a mere consideration for the diverse annual festivals that populated humanity. Our habits, our practices, our daily ways-of-being; consideration for the gods, for those celestial deities who occupied the deep of the night and marked the passage of Time.

Astrology today is still regarded by Roman Catholics as a dark art, so that a robust possibility of comparative theologies looks dim at first face. And indeed, without a knowledge of the night sky, one would be bereft of the art of understanding time, as it were, in the light of mythology. The mytho-logy, or reasoning which arises from a consideration for myth, belongs to a heuristic device (much like the Antikaithera Mechanism) adopted from pre-history for the sake of importing an understanding of the will of the gods, the seven moving in the twelve houses, the zodiacal ring of the year, The great Giants resting at the whirling peak of the world and the deluge below. As Levinas puts it in Time, Death, and God, the upward image discloses a curiosity which precedes all taboo. Science sees the world, and subjects it to the criticism of a mathematical consideration for the conditions of its being, its physics.

A consideration for Hinduism means not less than a consideration for the marks made by a consideration for Time in Hindu thinking. The calendrical culture of South Asia is one of many histories, one of many ways of being. A consideration for astrology is no plunging oneself into a dark art (no rash judgement!), but rather a plunging oneself into a question for the role and domain of astrology in making intelligible the very meaning of the texts under consideration; it would be rash to judge Great Hindu works without a consideration for the astrological cultures which produced them. The myths open themselves more freely to a reader who has an ear for astrological thinking, and even more so when they are not limited to such astrological thinking! But how rash are we to skip the elementary in order to appear as more advanced! 

The elementary stands as the guardian to thinking; when elements of thought are lacking in consideration, one thinks rashly, one acts impulsively. Consideration for the time of the other is a consideration which belongs to an even broader ethical thinking. The neglect of India is the neglect of a growing economy, a new consumer. Capitalism itself then wants a healthy India, an India with a healthy appetite.

But India consumes diversely, it is a marketplace of diverse cultures. And with that, diverse understandings of Time. This diversity in many places and in many ways implicates itself in a process of exchange, a multi-cultural gifting. To seek a monotheology in Indian thought thus abstracts skyward, away from the ground of daily existence, and toward the cultural background, toward the idea of a culture of thinking horo-theo-logically (rather than pan-, panen-, poly- et al).

It is perhaps uncanny to Middle-Eastern monotheologies to find in India a habit for divinizing the diverse ontological groups in the world, and yet for the throngs therein, for thinking oneself monotheologically. Generally, this leads to a thinking of brahman, abstract unity or monism. Yet the mono- in monism is not yet a monotheology.

There does stand before us an important question for consideration, and an important critique, one that aims to reach near the heart of Hindu thought, in order to better bring out the historical course of its monotheological thought, which is even now already well under way. It is perhaps the fate of Vaiṣṇavism to always be preparing the way for the arising of monotheological thought. And this, because it is always thinking horo-theo-logically. In abstraction, kāla stands as the supreme deity of the whole of the Hindu Pantheon.

Kāla, or Time, is the vision of a supreme and absolute deity, a God-over-all-other-gods. Time, as a theological product, as a product of thinking—theologically, ritually, annually, calendrically, horologically—is a thinking which produces a cultural fruit, in many cases, a diverse market-place of cults and rituals. These cultures interact as through the medium of shared calendars, public annual festivals, habits of gifting and exchange, of sacrifice, mercy, and renewal. The sacrificial mind dresses up the pleas of humanity to the hearts of the gods; it seeks a way into their hearts as through their stomachs. Fate is taken to be in the many moving hands of the gods, and with that, a certain fatalism arises which motivates the sacrificer to seek clemency, mercy.

Kāla slays all. None can withstand his approach forever. The thought here merges darkness with finitude, and gives rise to the thinking of death. Immanuel Levinas would have us think of what lay beyond death, so that the finitude of Time's grasp on life would appear as a demonic grip, and one broken by the final, fatal act of death. So that the Grim Reaper seems the constant companion of Time: one of the four horsemen at the advance of the end of history. But what is perhaps an even more frightening thought than the end of history itself: what if instead of pre-occupying thought with consideration for the fate of humanity, given as unavoidable and inevitable, so as to usher it in all the quicker, we had to think of future generations and all those yet to come, all those who are yet to inhabit a lifespace, yet to confront the questions and quests this lifespace opens up to them. What if we stopped preparing the world merely for death, but instead prepared it too for life?

The image of Time as Supreme Deity needs to be understood if Vaiṣṇavism is to uphold the mantle of monotheology. But it appears as if under the weight of a mythical thinking, inspired by a naive consideration for a super-stitious and pre-critical horo-theology (i.e., astrology). The calendar, the culture, their history, and very many of their visions of deities patently belong to such a mode of interpretation, and as such, our question concerns the interpretive principles under which our understanding obtains its object. To teach Hinduism as an elementary subject, so as to produce an Introduction, not merely as useful, but insightful, helpful in clarifying Hinduism beyond misunderstanding. To do this, one needs to broach the question of astrology for the student, not so as to lead them to think superstitiously; rather, mythologically, to help them better understand the abstract and practical roles that myth plays in Hindu culture and thought, in setting its traditional, annual, seasonal patterns.

The facet of South Asian religion I am concerned with is just that one which adores Time as Supreme, roughly defined as the kāla-vādins. The term, kāla-vadin, does implicate a specific if loosely bound historical group (Gauḍīya Vaiṣṇavas, Rāma-bhaktas, various Śaivas, and some groups of Śāktas can be said to belong to this group), or it can also simply refer to the group contributing the Atharva-Vedic hymns dedicated to kāla. Perhaps this latter might even include those earlier thinkers who first worked out the length of the year, and who considered its understanding to be a great riddle, as collated by J. Gonda in his work, Prajāpati and the Year. We might roughly view these then as two groups, since there is evident an earlier and a later in terms of the history of the concept of Time in South Asian literature. We do not mean to introduce a new religion where there was not one before; rather, we are using the term kāla-vādin in a formal sense, as an historical category of the understanding, one utilized in Hindu thinking and one we too might adopt for analytical ends (even if thereby doing so, we extend its meaning further).

 This facet would be best viewed without reduction to an incomplete reading, but its complexity and enormity evades a singular consideration on my part alone. Its role is increasingly clear to me, insofar as so much of what is thereby recognizable in South Asian religion reflects an intuition or notion of it, insofar as the people set their own life-patterns after it in one form or another. The timing of weddings by consideration for the proper muhūrta, the calculation of the Vedic or Vaiṣṇava calendar,  The timing of births and reading of fates in astrology—all of these belong to a broadly elementary "Hindu" intuition of kāla. Even the conflicting paces in the daily grind of both urban and rural life in South Asia still show deep regard for these intuitions.

Time, whether regarded by its "Western Sense" or by its "Asian Sense" is clearly a background condition for the thinking of human history in South Asia, as much as it is for that collective we call the West. Indeed, Time is no less a condition for the world of the mere animal! As such, it is an absolute background condition for being. The thought of Time's greatness refers to the remoteness of its idea as the background for lived spaces. Time is a basic condition. As a basis, it is also a baselessness or what is too remote to give itself in any basic way; i.e., a background. Time considered conceptually might give us such language as before and after, as past, present, and future, and as such, might be subject to J. M. McTaggart's logical critique. But if Time simply and truly shows itself as a basic baselessness, does not this suggest a patent contradiction too? Does not Time here become too absurd even to think?! Is Time no more than a great absurdity?

But such unserious thinking would have us ignore the basic truth of Time's conditional character: as a remote background, it perhaps does not stack up to the Eternal. Perhaps Time is not so Great as Eternity? Or have we simply lost sight of what is similar in them, the sempiternal? Is not the "forever and ever" of Time like that of Eternity? Or do we only regard as Time what is finite in one degree or another? 

Wednesday, May 25, 2016

Time and Light

Time, in abstraction, “appears” as if a visible event. Time as Light constitutes the rate of the propagation of an event. In this respect, even visualizing the past (as with time travel to a distant past) would be mere visualization, mere envisioning, and not per se ‘recovering the event in its originary passage of coming to be’. Time travel today, as fiction, envisions the technology, but does not understand the phenomenon well, and so devolves instead into hocus pocus, technological and narrative slight of hand. Serious consideration of the very meaning of temporality given in terms of its conceptual structure for this reason does not easily arise, and certainly not without the right sort of preparatory exercises. 
We can analyze time horologically, as with our attempts to keep track of it via natural and mechanical clocks and calendars. Such analysis affords us a view of Time, a way of seeing it. But there are other analytical approaches which prove to be meaningful approaches to an understanding of Time. Perhaps if we are to first have an understanding of Time which might finally be regarded as comprehensive in its formalities, if not yet finished in its historical overtures—so that every generation will have a view of Time for a while, and then pass on in the face of a yet newer generation—we should aim at an understanding of the Being for whom the question of the meaning and nature of Time is at issue.
Time, in this respect, refers to Dasein’s finitude, and the urgency which this produces alongside the angst felt in thinking of death. Time is as if saturated by a sort of meaningfulness in this urgency which it presses upon Dasein to seek after. Dasein seeking to restore its past, seeking to reverse the flow of events, to invert as it were the arrow of entropy and tragedy, and so to cast itself back. What direction is this backward leading event? Is it even realizable in terms of our current physical ontologies which preference that of what is, what exists and can thus be seen, in opposition to that which is not, is no more? Or would we need first to learn a new language, one with newer grammatical rules and newer terms, a language which allowed for discourse on this redisclosure of events past? And how else would we expect to disclose a thing so illusive as time reversal?
We might at least imagine such a machine as would naturally arise from such a serious conversation;  and imagination here is at least somewhat important, since it evokes the visual element of Time. What does the person outside the machine witness when witnessing this event of time-reversal? What does the person within this field opened up by the machine witness looking outward at her audience?
Interstellar makes a state-of-the-art styled attempt at visualizing the current best modeling of the sorts of dynamics at play in such an event. The leap across space leads to a leap across Time, one which suggests a general angular function to Time, if not one that reverses events (though in the event of passing through the portal there arises a moment of such, two time-travellers cross paths while passing in opposite directions). In this film, there is a tacit need for visualizing, and hence a seduction into avoiding the deeper difficulties of conceiving Time travel. 
The passenger plays a role in opening up such a direction, such a field, if only as its passive witness. Would such a removal from the forward flow of Time appear to the passenger as a visual movement? Or would such eyes as we possess not be able to process higher dimensional structures? Would we not go blind to the passage between worlds? Wouldn't this be a dark moment, a moment without vision? 
If we have truly been dispossessed of a visual, it is perhaps because we have this instinct for the identity of Time and Light. 
Time is first of all an opening in the World, a Space, wherein events inspire and expire; history rolls itself underfoot by the inspiration of the novel, and the expiration of the institution. This opening is held together in unity by the passage of light from one event to another; seeing. It is being held open by a form of Time known as Dasein, as life. It is such an abstraction which thus opens the way for the easy envisioning of consciousness as light. But then we can see the difficulty, caught as we are by the seductions of envisioning everything, not allowing for thought of the blind moments, the moments when the eyes and all of our other instruments fail us as when we cannot see beyond the event horizon of the reversal. Opening up this particular sort of field doubtlessly produces such an event horizon. But what does that even look like? 
Would one see a hole, whereupon the other side showed some time in the deep past, as with Star Trek’s famous episode, The City on the Edge of Forever. Or would space simply warp the image of the other side from view? Would the vehicle appear to shrink from our eyes? Would it simply fade, as the good Doctor’s Tardis? Would there simply be a hole torn in spacetime, which some eyes could see and some not? Would the sudden loss of local mass impact and destroy the local spatial environment, witnesses included? Would we not have to witness from afar, through instruments? Would the hole simply close back up, or would a crack, an unalterable opening protrude into our local spacetime? Would the vision of us as we moved through this portal appear as if a redshifting movement, of a thing no longer but not yet gone from sight? Would each passing vision blockade and disrupt the motion of the next traveller? or would the visions merge as each new passenger entered, slowly fading over time? Would one be able to “set up shop” in this new environment, carved out of space and time, this crack as a new world to explore? 

So many questions await our response. Perhaps it is enough for the Time being that we let fiction tell us more about this event through the collective imagining of it. But at least we ought to know the questions we want fiction to put to the test. 

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

Death as Sleep

If Death is given in terms of a deep slumber, as given in the phrase--RIP--the life would be no more that a persisting restlessness. That restlessness could be likened again to a guilt as given in sleepless nights of isolation. Life would be among the most guilty of sins; survival would be the first of evils.


"Sleep well," would be the greatest of benedictions. 

But life must needs be conisidered in terms other than that of a mere opposition derived from the serious, or grave, thought of death. Human flourishing is the goal here, not mere morbidity, a mere wish for sleep. 

Heaven is a beautiful thought: the idea of paradise. If death were sleep, heaven would be a beautiful dream, and hell would be a nightmare. In this way does an afterlife take on the appearance of rest. 

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Doctor Whom: Part II

In our last episode, we considered a hypothetical genius, one who had managed to work out the complexities of time reversal, and had further managed to produce a technological device adequate to that same task. A technological marvel to all appearances, it features a transparent crystalline dome, so that the Doctor can witness the very turning of the tide of Time upon itself. The whole world stands outside the machine, he in its control deck. He inputs the necessary data, sets course for, say, the 12th century France, and executes the command sequence. The machine begins to whir and hum, and in front of his eyes, he sees the world appear as if

toooo

slooooowwww


dooooooooooowwwwwwwwwwwwnnnnnnnnnn.


And just like that, Time's flow has been curbed. A moment later (Time still travels forward inside), events which had just transpired a moment before, begin to repeat themselves, only this time, in reverse. 

What does he witness then? He watches more than just a clock travelling in a wayward direction. He sees the very world outside set itself into reverse. A rubber ball falling and bouncing will seem to gain energy rather than lose it to thermodynamic entropy. With each bounce it will shoot higher and higher, until it reaches a plateau of gravitational potential energy.


Our Doctor has certainly already anticipated this turn of affairs, but nothing can substitute for the very act of witnessing it. And so, with eyes wide open, he realizes that he should have to now describe this strange gravitational behavior. And at this point, we have to recognize that we have already entered into a fictional realm, simply because it is not one with which we are at all familiar. We never see the world behaving as the Doctor sees it. His vision, therefore, has to be recognized as speculative. Here, we only mean to ask what sort of things it might be possible for him to see.

A) He sees the World torn apart, down to the last particle

In this first scenario, he simply witness the reversal of the forces of Gravity, Electromagnetism, the Weak and Strong Nuclear forces, and the rest. As a result, the entire universe appears to fall apart; Time and Space are themselves undone.

Speaking generously, it remains difficult to believe anything could survive this.

B) He sees Gravity exhibit properties which preserve the attraction of masses and do not lead to infinite repulsion

Somehow, this scenario is like that of the athlete above, which allows him to flip onto a roof simply by doing a few preparatory flips. And yet, this build up of force, whatever we may call it, does not build up in such a way as to hurl him from the face of the Earth and into deep space.

How would a scientist describe this "gravitational" behavior? Would it seriously be nothing more than changing an addition sign to a subtraction sign, a positive to a negative, or the like? Is Time something which behaves like a video, just pre-recorded contiguous information that can be explored in any direction? If so, then behaviors like Gravity are not in fact fundamental forces, because the world would be fundamentally Timeless, and a fundamentally Timeless world could have Gravity only as an illusory appearance.

C) The World Becomes Opaque

We ought to really consider this other option, since it might be that the only way of reversing Time is to stand "outside" of it, granting it actually makes sense to suppose Time having an inside and an outside. But how then are these properties of past, present, and future?

Perhaps it is enough to regard the inside as presence, while the outside would be more akin to "pre-creation" or "post-devastation", or, if a contrast must be made directly against presence, then as non-being. 

But doesn't this imply annihilation? If one must travel all the way to a "place" prior to Time—one which is, by the same measure, posterior to Time—it seems that one would fall entirely outside the possible conditions for existence (at least as far as we know it).


Implications

Without wanting to entirely shut the conversation down (this blog is more intended to start the conversation), what is really possible here? Have we missed something vital? Or is Time Reversal really just a "non-starter"?

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Time Travel Prank!

Saturday, March 19, 2016

File Under Time: Amazonians Reference Time Through Gestures

This Article offers an interesting account of Time, and one which demonstrates a prehistoric deviation from Proto-Indo-European norms. As such, it may help to broaden our understanding of Time. 

Saturday, March 12, 2016

Existence, History, and the Oblivion of Time

Historical participation in civil life means, being-as-a-citizen. Ethics, in its primordial, existential manner of presentation, comes-forth, comes-into-being, as the initiation and repetition of the face-to-face encounter (qua Levinas).

Seeing the right, Hearing of the right, Speaking the right—the cor-rect, (to wit, "the True")—amounts to participation in civic life.

How one chooses to share this, depends upon one's dispositional attitude toward being, whether given as sattva, rajas, or tamas (existence, passion, or ignorance).
Have we yet become adequately existential about existence yet? Have we understood the phenomenon of existence just as it has given itself to us yet? Such is the basis of the Whole-being of ontology.
Have we yet become passionate about history? Have we yet to see the day of history, in its Whole-ness? Or have we still just fragments of it? Will we lose history? Does not a crippled man better appreciate the health of the healthy? Such is the drive toward historicity.
Have we yet overcome our ignorance of Time? We are, each of us, finite, by virtue of history. This we know by virtue of death: All men are mortal. Quid Est Demonstratum: Socrates is mortal.
Socrates, in his dying breath, teaches us about civic life. He, the wisest of the Athenians (because at least he was aware of his own ignorance!) would not reject civic life (He would have thereby embraced banishment!). "Better the Hemlock than Exile!"
Shame follows the exile for the rest of his life. "No longer a citizen of the polis, No longer a participant in democracy, the rule of the many, by virtue of law, over the chaotic gifts of nature's assignments; to wit, "one's own genetic nature".
Ethics today is a serious assignment for us all. How to participate in civic life? How to end our days, here on Earth, by virtue of teaching ethical phronesis (φρόνησις), excellence in goodness, the quintessential Virtue of virtues; (सं॰, "शूद्द-सत्त्व")?
Such serious questions arise among us philosophers in these, the Times of great crisis! The existentialists were driven to rethink history anew because of WWII! Now is upon us this great task: to think! Now, and without hesitation! To be a sage of our times! To announce by virtue of ethical action our attendance to the needs of the many for wisdom: to be a philosopher in a time of war.


Turning the Conversation

If civic life is to lead, on the whole, toward excellence in goodness (or rather, to a verdant contest of goods), one needs to turn the conversation toward higher avenues. In an age of internet debates, where quick wit and sharp tongue make for the major virtues of trolls, there arises an evident need to frame the Trump phenomenon within this culture of soundbites and half-lies.

The frustration felt by victims of internet trolls is not different from that felt by opponents of Trump. With each attack, his strengths in the media spotlight grow, as if the very medium through which he was arising acted to prevent his verbal assailants from success. Even as severe a roast by the POTUS as this must be considered as short of fully halting Trump's meteoric rise. Words are not the strength of his supporters, so high-minded burns must also be considered out of their general purview or understanding. Such jokes "go right over their heads" (though perhaps not at all intended otherwise).

In my thinking about the national stage our current presidential candidates have ascended, I see a contest in which the media is itself the message. We citizens are left with a choice: upon whom to bequeath the mantle of POTUS. Do we seek merely to be entertained, as by bread and circus? Or do we seek excellence in goodness? Are we to be ruled over by our inferiors?

The legacy of great presidents gives us pause to recognize the dawning of a quickly approaching time, a post-Obama presidency. Even should the Republican obstruction of Obama's judicial nominees survive him, and the next president-elect nominate Obama himself to the Supreme Court, the office of the POTUS shall be in new hands, a new chapter to be written. Will it be America's final chapter? Or among its earliest? Only Time will tell. But let us not forget that the lucky few, we US citizens, are helping to write it.


The Danger of Comedy

"Fight gravity with levity!"
Friedrich Nietzsche


In wanting to humiliate a thin-skinned will—to shame it into turning from its aims—we may be tempted to resort to comedy. But there is a crucial and dangerous seriousness to this turn in American politics which cannot simply be laughed away; our laughter may yet come to be considered by later thinkers as a willful ignorance of the coming days. A serious discussion of Trump's public appeal is indispensable to the outcome of this next year.

34 Senate seats are up for grabs this election year. The slender majority of Senate Republicans make them generally less difficult in working together with the minority of Democrats. The House of Congress is another story. A total of 496 seats are up for re-election! As such, the real battle for the future is much closer to home than the office of POTUS. It will be fought out, state to state, district to district, in promoting and electing local democratic leadership to stand with the president-elect come November (or to oppose his fascist fantasy, should the worst come to pass).

Today we still enjoy the luxury of comedy, of levity toward the absurd theatrics of this never-before-seen Donald Drumpf drama. But this thin-skinned and small-minded willfulness did manage to pull us into what is now the Middle East quagmire. "Democratizing Iraq" hardly qualifies as a hot topic in the media today. Men obsessed with a New American Century—lacking the graces of an eye or mind for international diplomacy yet brimming with passionate greed—brought the US economy to its knees, accelerating our crumbling infrastructure and tearing open old wounds, which have now begun to fester in the form of degraded race relations. The medicine is working; but the patient may still die.

Comedy may thus turn out to have merely been a way of consoling ourselves: "I did everything I as an individual citizen might have been expected to do. I ridiculed him, and slighted his attempts at politicizing."

Let us not content ourselves with belittling Trump for, however small his heart, he still casts an intimidating shadow over civic life today. Civic participation which turns the conversation to higher avenues is necessary for all of those of us seriously concerned about his untimely rise; democracy is the blood-and-sweat sacrifice we must offer in return for our freedoms.